Good But Not Great–My Take on The Hobbit–Beth Trissel

2012-hobbit-Bear in mind that I’m a HUGE Lord of the Rings fan. I’m not wearing an Elvin cape around the neighborhood like one young woman I know, but near enough. I love that series and often re watch it. And yes, I’ve actually read all of the books.

So, imagine my excitement when I learned about the making of The Hobbit and the opportunity for another trek back to my beloved Middle Earth. I couldn’t wait to see it, although at some level I wondered how the film could possibly compare with ‘The Rings’ trilogy. After all, this initial story was overlooked in making the original series, presumably because it wasn’t considered meaty enough, so that caused me to question how Peter Jackson could create an epic trilogy out of this first, simpler tale. And then characters disappeared from some of my favorite British TV shows, getting killed off so they could be in The Hobbit. I comforted myself by saying, ‘They’ve gone to a better place. Middle Earth.”

As always, I loved being back in The Shire.  Some scenes in The Hobbit are visually spectacular and it’s amazing how the movie was filmed, but I didn’t connect with the characters as I did in The Rings trilogy. The Hobbit isn’t nearly as engaging. I grew more attached to Bilbo by the end of the movie, and Martin Freeman gave an excellent portrayal of the likable mild-mannered hobbit, but my emotions were lukewarm compared to the surge of affection I feel for Frodo, Sam, Merry and Pippin. And oh, man, did I miss Aragorn, Legalos, Arwin, Gimli, even Boromir…At least we still had the incomparable Gandalf.  And seeing him again was great.

Richard Armitage is outstanding as the Dwarf Lord Thorin Oakenshield, but I’m not attached to him. I miss the old gang. This fellowship lacks that wonderful sense of camaraderie in The Fellowship of the Ring. I’m not even sure who all the dwarfs are, and would only have winced slightly had most of them fallen off the side of the mountain that came violently to life in a most unlikely manner, with the exception of the young dwarf, Kili (played by Aiden Turner, whose death I grieved on the UK’s Being Human and haven’t watched it since). I wearied of endlessly fighting orks, trolls, wargs… Nor was I entirely clear as to the plot. In TLOTR,  we soon discovered what must be done to save Middle Earth and especially The Shire.

Yes, I will see the entire series of The Hobbit, though not imbued with the same enthusiasm I entered the theater with today. Yes, “Rings” fans should see The Hobbit. It’s worth viewing and you may feel differently. I, however, am kind of disappointed. And did I mention this is my only big movie outing of the year?

4 responses to “Good But Not Great–My Take on The Hobbit–Beth Trissel

  1. I had no problems connecting to the dwarves – thought the variety of ages and “looks” added to the story. Got the whole “Bilbo has a home, so he’ll help them regain theirs. Loved Richard Armitage’s take on Thorin, but NOT PJ’s idea of his “feud” with this white-skinned orcish villain – what was THAT all about? anyone with half a brain would NOT come down from the tree, and SIGH… just like Aragorn going over the cliff, that could have ruined it for me. I didn’t let it, oh well. Just another flaw in the film. The books are ALWAYS better, LOL.


  2. That really steams me when they don’t stick to the books. Mathair’s not too familiar with Tolkien, but The Hobbit is my favorite of his novels and I was so looking forward to seeing it on the big screen. I wish Hollywood would respect the material enough to give audience members it’s true form, and not worry about dramatizing it for Box Office bucks. Reading Purists, like myself, would much prefer that they stayed true to the material. Even if there are no surprises for us. Thanks for being so honest about it, Beth. I’ve asked my friends what they thought about it, but they never took the time to read the book.
    BTW Happy Holidays! 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s